Toasts: Should Not Be Important, May Be Blocked
I do not claim to be a UI/UX expert, nor do I play one on (Google) TV.
However, it stands to reason that things that are important should be visible for longer than a few seconds, wherever possible.
In other words, purely transient effects, such as a
the “ticker text” of a
Notification, should not be the sole
source of important information. It is far too easy for a user to
miss these, partly due to size (both tend to be small), but mostly
because they are short-lived. All the user needs to do is be distracted
for a few moments at the wrong time, and they will miss the important
If you want to use a
Notification ticker in addition to
something else, that is fine. Or, perhaps the “something else” is
sufficient for your needs, such as displaying the information in
a banner-style area within your activity. It just has to stick around
if it is truly important.
This is compounded by the fact that, on Android 4.1+, if the user
disables notifications, this also disables the display of a
Even the foreground activity cannot display a
Toast if notifications
are blocked for the app.
This behavior is flagged as a defect,
and so it is possible that
Toasts will return despite notifications
being blocked, or be allowed in
certain circumstances (e.g., processes with foreground priority).
But since users can block a
Notification (and, by current extension,
Toast), and since the ticker text and the
Toast are transient,
do not use them as the sole means of delivering important information.
Your users should be worth a better UI.
(also, thanks to Harri Smått for pointing out this issue!)Tweet